their condemnation is just

Sometimes, you have this glimmer of hope that things will become more clear. And as you think and search and converse, they become less so. True of my weekend and the attempt to answer “Whose Condemnation?” It’s a fun time. {But really.}

For a quick review of the issue at hand, we’re asking . . .

Who is to be justly condemned, according to Paul in Romans 3:8?

And why not do evil that good may come? — as some people slanderously charge us with saying. Their condemnation is just.

(1) Paul himself, if he were to actually say such things
(2) The people who falsely accuse Paul
(3) Anyone who says such things
(4) Or perhaps there’s another option

Allow me to get technical for a bit, because this one is no less than complicated. Unless you’re a fan of details, the concluding thoughts will be most worth your time. So if you’re not up for the technical stuff, scroll below the magnifying glass. {And don’t forget to read the votes on the original post. They’re pretty insightful.}

Let’s examine this briefly from four angles: the original Greek text, various English translations, grammar, and logic.

Using my I-don’t-know-much-about-Greek glasses, it looks as though the word “their” doesn’t really exist in some of the original writings, so maybe it was added for flow of thought. The sentence structure, no matter how you look at it, leaves things quite ambiguous.

Compare reliable translations, and you will essentially come up with all three possibilities (#1, #2, & #3). Some translations attempt to answer the question, but it would seem that this is simply a liberty taken by the translators.

As for the plain grammar of it, I personally think #1 makes the most sense.

And why not do evil that good may come? — as some people slanderously charge us with saying. Their condemnation is just.

Logically, #1 works. Paul was just talking about people who are condemning him. And so he basically says, “They have charged us with taking advantage of grace. If we are twisting the gospel in this way, they should be upset about that. But we’re not.”

Now, to be sure, the other options make sense as well. Which is why I’m going to go with the fourth option.

whose condemnation

In Romans 3:8, whom does Paul say should rightly be condemned? My vote is #4: “Perhaps there’s another option.” {Knew I should offer a way of escape . . .}

Let me explain my vote with three quick statements.

1. Answers #1 & #3 go together. So if #1 is true, #3 is also true, and vice versa.
2. All three possible answers are logical and biblical in the context of the passage.
3. The answer is unclear, so perhaps we shouldn’t seek to make it clear.

I think our proper response to all of this is two-fold.

Aim to know everything about the Word of God.
And revel in the fact that, try as you might, you never will.

[image credit: wikipedia commons,]

2 thoughts on “their condemnation is just

  1. Yeah, I guess all three options make some sense, and I didn’t really explain my view very much. I mostly just gave it lol. I guess I’ll try to explain it a little now.

    We have asked “whose condemnation is just?” but there’s another question especially since you pointed out that “their” may not even always be there. The question is, “what is being condemned?” or “what is the condemnation?” or maybe simply “what condemnation?”

    In the near context, it seems that what is being condemned is the false doctrine which some accuse Paul of teaching. Once that is answered, the “whose” question may be answered as well. It would be those people who were accusing Paul. Their condemnation of the false teaching is just although Paul points out that their accusations of him teaching it are slanderously inaccurate.


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s